After decades of mystery, the remains found in Marlborough, New Hampshire, in 1974 have been identified as Nancy Gale Erickson. Advances in DNA technology confirmed her identity, bringing closure to her family. Investigators are now seeking information about the circumstances surrounding her death, appealing to those who knew her in New York, Florida, and Vermont.

After more than five decades of mystery, New Hampshire authorities have finally identified the woman whose body was discovered in the woods near Marlborough in 1974 as Nancy Gale Erickson, bringing long-awaited answers to a case that has haunted investigators and her family for generations.

On April 16, 1974, the remains of a young woman were found in a wooded area off Route 124 in Marlborough, New Hampshire. At the time, she had no identification, and detectives believed she had died in the late fall of 1973. For years, the case went cold, with the victim remaining a "Jane Doe" despite sporadic efforts to uncover her identity.

The breakthrough came in 2021 when Erickson’s family reported her missing to the Brattleboro Police Department. Advances in forensic DNA testing enabled investigators to match DNA from the remains to samples provided by Erickson’s siblings, confirming her identity in 2025.

The life and disappearance of Nancy Erickson

Nancy Gale Erickson was 21 years old when she disappeared. Born and raised in Elmira, New York, she earned a nursing degree from Corning Community College before moving to Tampa, Florida, to be with her mother and siblings. She worked as a nurse at Tampa General Hospital but abruptly left Florida in 1973, taking only a duffel bag with her. Her family believes the emotional toll of her nursing work may have contributed to her sudden departure.

Erickson’s journey took her to Vermont, where she was arrested in Bellows Falls for stealing a car in October 1973. She received probation and remained in Brattleboro, working at the Brattleboro Retreat, a mental health hospital, and living at the Community House. She was last seen leaving her job at the Retreat on October 30, 1973, and was never heard from again.

Ongoing investigation and appeal for information

With her identity now confirmed, investigators are shifting focus to uncovering the circumstances surrounding Erickson’s death. New Hampshire State Police Detective Sgt. Kelly LaPointe emphasized the significance of restoring Erickson’s identity and the renewed effort to understand how and why she died. Authorities are appealing to anyone who may have known Erickson during her time in New York, Florida, or Vermont, particularly former staff at the Brattleboro Retreat, residents of the Community House in 1973, students from Corning Community College (1971–1972), and Tampa General Hospital staff.

Anyone with information is urged to contact the New Hampshire Cold Case Unit tip line at (800) 525-5555 or submit a tip online.